5031 W Lake Road Chautauqua, NY 14757
Listing by: NYS ALLIANCE / ERA Team Vp Real Estate / Ruth Nelson - Contact:  716-708-9980

  5031 W Lake Road Chautauqua, NY 14757

Active
$1,495,000 (USD)
4
BED
3.2
BATH
4,500
SQFT

Description

The iconic Red Brick Farm property is located along Route 394 on the well-trafficked N. Lake corridor between Chautauqua Institution and the Village of Mayville. The compound includes seven buildings situated on approximately 25 acres of land. This turn of the century property was originally a dairy farm which the current owner painstakingly converted into a restaurant, living and retail spaces. The House is set up to operate as a restaurant on the main level with living quarters on the second and third floors. Once inside you'll be impressed by the many original architectural details which were preserved including original hardwood floors, mantles, stairwell and pocket doors. This stately brick home is a prominent feature of the property with its wonderful wraparound porch and handsome brick facade. The Barn has been fully reconstructed inside and is a feast for the eyes with its soaring gambrel ceiling and versatile main floor and loft spaces. The Milking Barn and Produce Stand are both adjacent to the main parking area and would make for wonderful additional retail spaces. The big red Retail One & Two buildings (constructed in 2003) are located behind the main center and can be accessed via paved driveway off of the main road. This service road provides access to additional parking in the rear and out to the immense pole barn. Both Retail One & Two buildings have suffered from water intrusion due to failure of the roofs. Condition issues also exist in the basements of both of these buildings. The level grounds would make for a variety of delightful outdoor uses and they help give a buffer from surrounding properties. The rear of the property features a pond, is partially wooded and leads to the gas well. The private gas well provides supplemental gas in addition to the existing National Fuel service. With so many exciting things happening in our region, now's the perfect time to bring your vision to life here and revitalize this incredible, one-of-a-kind property! Also listed as MLS R1674585.

MLS #:
R1680054
Taxes
$13,758
Lot Size
24.6 acres
Type
Single-Family Home
Year Built
1908
Style
Farmhouse
School District
Chautauqua Lake
County
Chautauqua County

Listed By

Ruth Nelson, ERA Team Vp Real Estate, Contact: 716-708-9980
Source
NYS ALLIANCE
Last checked May 8 2026 at 3:46 PM GMT+0000
Bathroom Details
Interior Features
  • Gas Water Heater
  • Dishwasher
  • Separate/Formal Dining Room
  • Guest Accommodations
Lot Information
  • Agricultural
  • Irregular Lot
Property Features
  • Fireplace: 0
  • Foundation: Stone
Heating and Cooling
  • Gas
  • Forced Air
  • Zoned
  • Multiple Heating Units
  • Central Air
Basement Information
  • Walk-Out Access
Flooring
  • Varies
  • Hardwood
Exterior Features
  • Roof: Metal
  • Roof: Shingle
  • Roof: Architectural
Utility Information
  • Utilities: Sewer Connected, Water Source: Well, Electricity Connected
  • Sewer: Connected
Parking
  • No Garage
Stories
  • 3
Living Area
  • 4,500 sqft
Additional Information: ERA Team Vp Real Estate | 716-708-9980
Location
   
Calculate drive times to this property
 
Powered by INRIX® Drive Time

Powered by Walk Score®

Estimated Monthly Mortgage Payment

*Based on Fixed Interest Rate withe a 30 year term, principal and interest only

Listing price
Down payment
%
Interest rate
%
Mortgage calculator estimates are provided by ERA Team VP Real Estate and are intended for information use only. Your payments may be higher or lower and all loans are subject to credit approval.
Disclaimer: Copyright 2026 New York State Alliance. All rights reserved. This information is deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. The information being provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data last updated 5/8/26 08:46